School board strikes a blow for the timid and fainthearted

Among memorable lines from the 1985 classic Pee-wee’s Big Adventure is one in which protagonist Pee-wee Herman tells admiring love interest Dottie that he doesn’t need anyone: “You don’t wanna get mixed up with a guy like me. I’m a loner, Dottie. A rebel.”

Were that movie made today, it would seem likely that last word would have to be substituted, most likely with something bland and insipid, such as “nonconforming dissenter” or “quirky eccentric.”

The word rebel scares people.

Consider that the South Burlington (Vt.) School Board recently voted to drop the “Rebel” name at South Burlington High School for the coming school year. For more than 55 years South Burlington High School has used “Rebels” as its nickname, said to be in recognition of the city’s secession from Burlington many years before. In its early years, the school had an old-style Confederate colonel mascot, but that was dropped decades ago.

Superintendent David Young told the school board in February that it had become “crystal clear” to him that the nickname “is interfering with all students’ ability to feel safe and included in our schools.”

No details were provided on how a word – one associated with individuals such as George Washington, Martin Luther King Jr. and Gandhi – was “interfering with all students’ ability to feel safe and included … ”

According to an Associated Press story, the move to change the name came about because of a gradual shift in the largely white school, whose population is now nearly 20 percent nonwhite, said South Burlington High School Interim Principal Patrick Phillips. He said the nickname has created discomfort for some students.

I’m not aware of the racial makeup of South Burlington High, but according to the 2010 census, South Burlington itself was 90 percent white, 5.4 percent Asian, 1.9 black, 1.9 percent Hispanic. Two percent were classified as two or more races, and Native Americans, Pacific Islander and “other races” made up one-half of one percent or less of the town’s population.

Of course, that doesn’t mean that a significant percentage of non-white students haven’t moved into the school in recent years.

However, it seems somewhat condescending to assume that non-whites are automatically offended by the word “rebel.”

There had been a push to allow the community to vote on the mascot issue, but that was rejected by the school board.

South Burlington resident Sandy Dooley was among those opposed to a public vote.

“I think that every student, every child who participates in our education programs here in South Burlington has a right to be in an environment that in every respect supports his or her opportunity to take full advantage of what we’re offering here. And I think there’s ample evidence that the ‘Rebel’ identifier interferes with that,” she told the Associated Press.

Again, no evidence was provided on how the “rebel identifier” interferes with participation in education programs.

South Burlington students will vote today on three names to replace “rebels”: Huskies, Pride and Wolves. Inspiring. Jellyfish would seem more fitting, although it seems unfair to punish students for the sins of their lily-livered fathers, mothers and administrators.

No word on when the South Burlington School Board will take aim at striking Ethan Allen from its textbooks. After all, Vermont was founded by Allen and other “rebels” who sought independence from New York, seeing themselves “as a distinct region outside the legitimate jurisdiction of New York.”

Although Vermonters fought the British during the American Revolution, they didn’t join the fledgling United States at the outset of war, as both New York and New Hampshire wanted the territory for themselves.

Instead, in 1777, Vermonters declared independence, wrote their own constitution and formed the Republic of Vermont, which lasted until 1791, when the state was admitted to the Union as the 14th state.

Others who could be in the South Burlington School Board’s crosshairs include the Founding Fathers, most certainly considered “rebels” by Great Britain; Toussaint Louverture and Jean-Jacques Dessalines, who led a rebellion against colonial powers and helped Haiti to freedom in the early 19th century; Martin Luther, who rebelled against the Roman Catholic church and helped usher in the Protestant Reformation; Nelson Mandela, famed anti-apartheid activist; most any of the American Civil Rights leaders, who were considered rebels by Jim Crow advocates; and religious figures such as Moses, Jesus Christ and Muhammad.


14 thoughts on “School board strikes a blow for the timid and fainthearted

      • I´ve seen this in ´community´politics for decades….puff up a mountain about nothing, bawl and shout and gain recognition as ´leaders of the community´ from those who have money to hand out and need votes. Thus the ´community´ is almost obliged to go through these people to get anything done that needs funding which reinforces their acquired status.

  1. I am so saddened by the increasing attempts across the country to erase any whiff of the more uncomfortable bits of our history, using this ridiculous notion of political correctness and inclusion. We should not be shielding ourselves or our children from ugliness in history. We should be remembering ugliness so we can better understand the need to avoid it in the future. Of course, as you point out, the word “rebel” is so interwoven into the fabric of American history that it’s not even a consistently ugly word and in many instances should be celebrated. Really, the day we stop understanding that rebellion is at the heart of our country, is the day our country comes to an end. Just my thoughts.

    • Very well stated, Sarah. We’re a nation built on the idea of rebellion. Whether it was Pilgrims “rebeling” against what they perceived as wrongheadedness within the Church of England, Huguenots who came to North America to escape persecution, Roger Williams and Anne Hutchinson being booted from Massachusetts – and moving to what would become Rhode Island – for failing to conform to prevailing religious norms, the American Revolution, Americans moving to Texas to assist with the revolt against Mexico or any number of other events, we are a nation steeped in rebellion.

  2. Vermont is notoriously rebellious and independent. I believe there is a secessionist move afoot, too.

    Call me a “rebel” and I’ll wear the moniker proudly. I’m about the only person I know who doesn’t own a TV, for instance. Thus do I rebel against the stinkthink that is foisted on the public as news, entertainment, and advertising.

    Maybe the South Burlington school board should consider “Conformists,” “Monotonists,” or “Wimps” as alternative nicknames.

    • Amen across the board. I find it interesting that if you look back at the early days of our nation, and before it was established, places such as Vermont, Rhode Island and New Hampshire, which are particularly noted as havens for “progressives,” especially the first two, were flagrantly independent. Vermont, of course, was an independent entity for 14 years. Rhode Island was the first colony to declare independence from Great Britain, boycotted the 1787 Constitutional Convention, initially refused to ratify the Constitution and was the final state to do so, in 1790. New Hampshire, with its motto of ‘Live Free or Die’ has also been noted for an independent streak.

      I wonder what the founders would think of what’s become of their states.

      • I don’t think the founders would recognize any part of the world we live in. it’s interesting, though, that so many of them were fascinated by machine technology. Obviously Jefferson and Franklin, but Washington and Hamilton–and probably others–also were. Hamilton sent spies to England to pirate new inventions.

  3. Pingback: Best of the Blogs (5-26-2017) | Civil War Chat

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s